XML Persian Abstract Print


Download citation:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:

Haghighat-Manesh E, Shahraki L, Haghighy M, Vaez H. Quality of General Medical Theses; A Ten-Year Appraisal. , Iranian Journal of Medical Education. 2026; 26 :149-159
URL: http://ijme.mui.ac.ir/article-1-5983-en.html
Department of Microbiology and Virology, Faculty of Medicine, Zabol University of Medical Sciences, Zabol, Iran. , vaezhamid84@gmail.com
Abstract:   (4 Views)
Introduction: Research competency is a fundamental component of medical education, equipping future students to critically appraise evidence, identify methodological limitations, and translate research findings into practice. Undergraduate theses provide an opportunity to develop these competencies through the formulation of research questions, critical review of the literature, study design, data analysis, and academic reporting. The quality of theses may therefore provide insights into the effectiveness of research training, supervisory practices, methodological guidance, available resources, and assessment procedures. Previous studies have documented considerable variation in thesis quality, particularly in study design, sampling procedures, methodological rigor, literature engagement, and interpretation of findings. Such shortcomings may be particularly relevant in resource-constrained settings, although limited resources do not necessarily equate to poor research quality. Against this background, the present study assessed the scientific quality of undergraduate medical theses completed at Zabol University of Medical Sciences over a ten-year period, examining study designs, the quality of individual thesis sections, and methodological and reporting shortcomings.
Methods: This document-based cross-sectional study examined 141 undergraduate medical theses completed between 2011 and 2021 academic years and archived at Zabol University of Medical Sciences. Theses were eligible if assessable copies were available; postgraduate and residency theses were excluded. Data were extracted using a structured form and an adapted checklist covering sex, study design, academic department, thesis consultant, and defense score. Thesis quality was evaluated across 11 domains: title, abstract, problem statement, literature review, objectives, research questions and hypotheses, methods, findings, discussion and conclusion, recommendations, and references. Each item was rated on a five-point scale (0–5), with domain scores interpreted as inappropriate (0–1), poor (1–2), moderate (2–3), good (3–4), or very good (4–5). Two medical education experts checked face and content validity using CVR and CVI forms covering necessity, relevance, clarity, and simplicity. Categorical variables were reported as frequencies and percentages, whereas domain scores were summarized using means, standard deviations, minimums, and maximums. An overall quality score was not calculated because item counts and domain weightings were unavailable. The study received ethical approval from the Ethics Committee of the National Agency for Strategic Research in Medical Education.
Results: Of the 141 theses, 88 (62.4%) were authored by female students and 53 (37.6%) by male students. A thesis consultant was identified in 98 theses (69.5%), whereas 43 (30.5%) had no consultant. Descriptive designs predominated (n = 92; 65.2%), followed by case–control studies (n = 35; 24.8%) and clinical trials (n = 14; 9.9%). This way, approximately two-thirds of the theses employed descriptive designs. The largest proportions of theses were affiliated with obstetrics and gynecology (n = 28; 19.9%), pediatrics (n = 21; 14.9%), infectious diseases (n = 15; 10.6%), anesthesiology (n = 11; 7.8%), and radiology (n = 11; 7.8%). Obstetrics and gynecology accounted for eight case–control studies (22.8% of all case–control studies), whereas anesthesiology contributed seven clinical trials (50.0% of all clinical trials). Official defense scores were concentrated in the upper range: 16–17 for six theses (4.3%), 17.01–19 for 123 (87.2%), and 19–20 for 12 (%8.5). The title domain received the highest mean score (M = 4.57, SD = 0.43), followed by the problem statement (M = 4.07, SD = 0.27), literature review (M = 4.03, SD = 0.40), objectives (M = 4.03, SD = 0.20), and research questions and hypotheses (M = 4.01, SD = 0.20), all rated as very good. Abstracts (M = 3.82, SD = 0.76), materials and methods (M = 3.83, SD = 0.45), findings (M = 3.17, SD = 0.66), and recommendations (M = 3.58, SD = 1.30) were rated as good. References (M = 2.86, SD = 0.94) and discussion and conclusion (M = 2.90, SD = 0.50) had the lowest mean scores, falling within the moderate range. Frequently identified deficiencies included the omission of study settings and time frames from titles, key findings from abstracts, and up-to-date evidence from literature reviews. Other shortcomings involved inadequate descriptions of laboratory procedures, eligibility criteria, and variable roles. In the discussion sections, findings were not always adequately examined in relation to supporting and contradictory evidence from previous studies, with limited critical analysis of areas of agreement and disagreement. As item-level frequency data were unavailable, these deficiencies were described qualitatively.
Conclusion: The evaluation of undergraduate medical theses indicated that, although abstracts, methods, and findings generally received satisfactory ratings, methodological reporting and the discussion and conclusion sections were comparatively weaker. The predominance of descriptive designs also points to the importance of developing students’ capacity to select research designs that appropriately address their research questions. Incorporating explicit quality criteria into pre-defense thesis assessments, with particular attention to methodological reporting and the interpretation of findings, could help identify weaknesses at an earlier stage. Providing students with formative feedback before the defense may further improve the scientific quality of their theses.
 
Full-Text [PDF 451 kb]   (4 Downloads)    
Type of Study: Original research article | Subject: Community Based Medicine
Received: 2026/08/13 | Accepted: 2026/10/12 | Published: 2026/04/30 | ePublished: 2026/04/30

Send email to the article author


Rights and permissions
Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

© 2026 All Rights Reserved | Iranian Journal of Medical Education

Designed & Developed by : Yektaweb